• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat
September 7, 2008 7:05 PM PDT

Apple admits it didn't invent the iPod

Posted by Chris Matyszczyk
  • Font size
  • Print

You know they'll make a movie out of this one. Well, at least something with "based on a true story" in small letters after the title.

The iPod was, apparently, invented not by some genius at Apple (not even a British one) but by a British furniture salesman who left high school at 15 and still has not been paid a dime for his brilliance.

London's Daily Mail is claiming that court documents prove that Apple has finally acknowledged Kane Kramer, a 52-year-old inventor who left high school 37 years ago, as the true father of the iPod.

(And to think that all this time I've been thinking if it wasn't Steve Jobs, then it had to be Bono.)

Emile Berliner. The man who invented the 'disc record'.

(Credit: CC Clydesan)

Apple flew Mr. Kramer to the US to give evidence in its defense against Burst.com, a company that claimed it held the true technological patents of the little plastic music box. It used his original scribbles, made in 1979, of a little plastic music box that, at the time, could only hold 3.5 minutes of music. Or roughly half of Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody.

Mr. Kramer secured a worldwide patent on his invention, which he then called the IXI. But, in one of those typical business tales of woe unlimited, he had a slight difference of opinion with his business partners and couldn't find the $120,000 he needed to renew that patent.

And so the Kramer Brainchild was open to adoption by any and every Seinfeld who lived down the corridor. Still, his scribbles and patents appear to have saved Cupertino's finest a lot of money.

"I was up a ladder painting when I got the call from a lady with an American accent from Apple saying she was the head of legal affairs and that they wanted to acknowledge the work that I had done," Mr. Kramer told the Daily Mail.

He added: "I must admit that at first I thought it was a wind-up by friends. But we spoke for some time, with me still up this ladder slightly bewildered by it all, and she said Apple would like me to come to California to talk to them."

Burst.com's counsel grilled Mr Kramer for 10 hours. You will not be surprised to hear that the Brit never cracked.

Perhaps he kept his concentration by wondering whether it would be Ralph Fiennes, or perhaps even Pierce Brosnan, who will be playing him in the movie version.

Mr. Kramer is now negotiating with Apple to see how much they might pay him for saving them far more than the $10 million of their Burst settlement. Um, I mean, for being the first person to imagine that you could reveal your true anti-social self by singing along to your plastic music box in remarkably full forms of public transport.

Though he has never actually bought an iPod ("Apple did give me one but it broke down after eight months," he said) Mr. Kramer is not waiting to see how much Apple might pay him for his past brilliance.

He has one more plan for securing not only his own future but that of his wife and three children. (Short of money, he had to sell his house last year and move his family into rented digs.)

He is now working on something called the Monicall, a device that records phone calls and then emails them as audio files to the participants.

Might I suggest he puts an 'i' in front of the brand name? Something tells me that will make it far more marketable.

Chris Matyszczyk is an award-winning creative director who advises major corporations on content creation and marketing. He brings an irreverent, sarcastic, and sometimes ironic voice to the tech world. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 14 comments
by cyberDJ-2038765336053745013836 September 8, 2008 4:36 AM PDT
Everybody knows Apple didn't invent the iPod.

We just need Apple to admit that the iPod isn't the best player on the market.
Market-share domination doesn't necessarily translate to product superiority.
Reply to this comment
by arosania September 8, 2008 7:10 AM PDT
Yeah, right... just after Microsoft admits Vista is a failure, as per your last sentence.

Geez... get a life...
by geotopia September 8, 2008 9:30 AM PDT
Feature wise and by price, it's obvious that the iPod isn't the best on the market. One of the best, but not the best. HOWEVER, it's not the hardware, but the PC/Mac host and iTunes ecosystem with which it plays so nicely that makes it the leader. Apple really had that one figured out back in 2001, when it looked like such a gamble. iPod's success is old news, but the future question is whether AppleTV and the iPhone will similarly succeed in dominating the market.
by joetesta70 September 8, 2008 11:02 AM PDT
Ummm...it's actually the best player, let's face it. That's why people like it.

Apple stole the Windows interface from Xerox too. That's the way the industry works sometimes...

$teve Job$ is still a greedy creep.
Reply to this comment
by JonB. September 8, 2008 11:51 AM PDT
Get it right. Apple ask Xerox if they could use it, because the PARCS staff had no commercial plan for the interface.
MS settled out of court with Apple after MS addmited that they had stolen the interface version from Apple (MS's Windows 3.1) after Apple won't sell it to them.
by movie_demon September 9, 2008 5:40 AM PDT
Jobs is a greedy creep, I'll give you that - but he didn't steal the Windows interface from Xerox. At that point in time, there was no such thing as Windows, and Microsoft was still selling DOS.

What he got from Xerox was the idea for a graphical user interface and a mouse. You could make an argument that he stole it, but it wasn't like he broke in - they invited him. And it was technology that they had kind of shelved because they decided it wasn't appropriate for their market.

So Jobs took it and made it the Mac OS... and then Bill Gates (who used to be a greedy creep, but now not so much) stole it from Jobs and THAT became Windows.
by GuyBlaise September 8, 2008 8:56 PM PDT
Even though Mr Kramer didn't get full credit for his invention, sooner or later he will be recognized.
Still his mind never stopped working. His future invention called Monicall should be a great product.
As the Berbers of Algeria say,"Intelligence is like garden: uncultivated, there is no harvest."
http://guyblaise.com/
Reply to this comment
by stevenrich4472 September 10, 2008 7:16 PM PDT
The monicall is illegal in the USA, unless you tell all parities on the phone you are recording the phone call.
by baconstang September 9, 2008 12:16 AM PDT
So? The Vikings discovered North America....So?
Reply to this comment
by unclepain September 12, 2008 7:44 AM PDT
How can one discover a land mass that already has inhabitants on it? But I digress...
by RainCaster September 9, 2008 7:32 AM PDT
Invented or not, the earth still revolves around Steve Jobs.

We are not worthy!
Reply to this comment
by rebel101151 September 9, 2008 3:51 PM PDT
eventually jobs will be a washup and mac will be more "user friendly" and lose its mac touch.its only a matter of time.....good luck jobs i do love macs.
by LEPTANDRUM September 10, 2008 8:48 AM PDT
And I thought the Audible Otis was the first on the scene. Check with Audible.com on this Mr Jobs
Reply to this comment
by amylynnhill September 10, 2008 7:22 PM PDT
The iPod is NOT the best mp3 player out there. I am in love with the SanDisk line, and love the Rhapsody music service. Why would I pay a dollar a song when I can just pay 15 bucks a month and download over 2 million songs!?!!?! And I have owned the same SanDisk player for almost 2 years now. Their warranty service is awesome too, it's lifetime so that means if it ever breaks I can call them, they send me prepaid shipping labels, I send it back, they either fix it or send me a new one. Can't beat it for about 1/4 the price of a lame iPod.
Reply to this comment
advertisement

In the news now

Yahoo's Decker strong contender for CEO

Sources say the president of the embattled Internet search pioneer has been through two rounds of interviews with the board.


Gadget extravaganza in Las Vegas

CES 2009 is in full swing. Highlights so far include Palm's WebOS and Pre device, Microsoft's Windows 7 beta, and much more.


About Technically Incorrect

Chris Matyszczyk brings a fresh and irreverent perspective to the tech world in his CNET blog, Technically Incorrect. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Technically Incorrect topics

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right