• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat
December 1, 2008 7:00 AM PST

Top-notch Vietnamese software BKAV raises antivirus bar

Posted by Dong Ngo
  • Font size
  • Print

Quang Tu Nguyen has changed the landscape of network and computer security in Vietnam.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

Editors note: CNET editor and Crave contributor Dong Ngo is spending the next month in his homeland of Vietnam and plans to file occasional dispatches chronicling his impressions of how technology has permeated the culture there. Click here for more of Dong's stories from abroad.

HANOI, Vietnam--If you use any Internet-connected computer in Vietnam--and there are lots of them, with Internet cafes and Wi-Fi spots abounding in any city--chances are you'll find a little red plus sign at the bottom-right corner of the screen.

That's the icon of the most popular antivirus software here. It's called BKAV.

(A bit of background: if you've recently read reviews of Internet security products by our security editor Rob Vamosi, know that I am the one who designed the methodology involved in testing these applications. It's therefore natural for me to be curious about how people in various parts of the world are protected against malicious software.)

BKAV is short for Bach Khoa AntiVirus, with "Bach Khoa" being the Vietnamese name for the Hanoi University of Technology. The software was originally developed as a hobby by Quang Tu Nguyen, a student-turned-lecturer at the school. It's currently the flagship product of Bach Khoa Internetwork Security center (BKIS), of which Quang, now 33, is director.

Quang still lectures once in awhile, but he's primarily known as the man who has changed the landscape of network and computer security in Vietnam. His creation, BKAV, is in many ways just about the best security software you can find.

I visited Quang at the BKIS headquarters, an office that somewhat resembles CNET or any other high-tech company: cubicles and lots of computer screens are everywhere. There's one big exception, however: everybody is asked to remove their shoes before entering, which is not a standard business practice in Vietnam. The company is probably the cleanest workplace I've seen here yet.

The center has about 400 employees, 300 of whom are software engineers, mostly recruited in-house from the school. They are among the brightest computer science minds in the country. According to BKIS, the BKAV security software currently enjoys about 10.5 million users and more than 110,000 downloads daily. Currently, Vietnam has about 20 million Internet users and counting (out of a population of about 85 million), according to the Vietnamese Ministry of Information and Communication.

Despite its frill-free user interface, BKAV offers highly advanced protection.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

The majority of security software applications feature a couple of common annoyances: they take a long time to install, they take a long time (and sometimes some difficulty) to remove, and they slow down your machine. This is because in order to protect your computer, security software needs to interfere significantly with basic operations such as reading and writing files, checking network connections, and so on. It's a challenge to develop protection software that is simple yet effective.

After a few days of trying BKAV and a few hours of talking to Quang and his engineers, I found BKAV to be arguably the only security application so far that offers both those attributes.

First off, the software took literally one second to install on my Dell XPS 1330 laptop and two seconds to completely remove, each step requiring a single mouse click. The software also uses very few system resources when not performing a scan.

If you accept the default options, you can start/stop the scanning just by using the Enter and Escape key. There are absolutely no frills in the user interface. For those who have installed and used any Windows software before and like to get things done the fastest possible way, this is a pleasant surprise. And yet this is the least impressive thing about the software.

It's common for antivirus software to remove a threat by literally removing/quarantining infected files. Technically, this is a fast way to write code that generally works well as long as the infected files are the viruses themselves.

This does, however, pose problems when the virus is sophisticated enough to add itself to a critical system file or replace the legitimate system file with a compromised version that also carries malicious commands. There is a new trend of viruses that do just that, and there are currently a few of them in the wild. Using the standard method to remove them will result in crippling the operating system, making it impossible to log in, and causing the loss of common features such as cut and paste or the ability to go on to the Internet.

(I actually sat down in the BKIS labs and tried a few known antivirus software applications against two specimens of these nasty viruses, including one identified by Symantec as Infostealer.Gampass and another identified by McAfee as Generic.dx. It's important to note that different security firms might identify the same virus differently, and sometimes a new virus can be identified as an existing virus. The applications, collectively, did detect and remove the viruses but also rendered the system unusable afterward.)

BKAV, by contrast, deals with each threat (and its variants) individually by dissecting its codes and meticulously countering exactly whatever it is the virus is designed to do. This is a lot of work, and it takes dedication. Quang and his colleagues take turns working literally around the clock to discover new threats and develop updates to counter them, typically within 24 hours.

Their effort results in two things: first, it's close to impossible for BKAV to register false detection. This is because once a threat is identified, BKAV goes deeper and scrutinizes the coding to find out exactly how it should be dealt with. This process at the same time verifies whether the detected threat is real. Second, BKAV is able to remove the malicious code without harming the system. Most of the time, you don't need to restart the computer for the cleaning to get done, either.

Unlike other software that gives you lots of flashy warnings and progress displays, BKAV takes care of threats in a rather unceremonious way. Often you wonder if your computer has actually been swept.

Taking up only roughly 13MB after installation (as opposed to hundreds of megabytes in other applications), BKAV is capable of protecting your computer against and removing all threats including viruses, trojans, spyware, rootkits, and malicious links spread through e-mail or or Yahoo chat. BKIS also offers network and enterprise protection solutions.

BKIS' technical support is available 24/7. All support is free; you just have to pay for the toll call.

(Credit: Dong Ngo/CBS Interactive)

(Speaking of Yahoo, if you live in Vietnam, you might wonder why Yahoo isn't doing so well in the United States. Yahoo Mail and Messenger are the first choice among Vietnamese teenagers and young adults when it comes to Internet-based communication. And teens and young adults are the majority of Internet users here. Also, Yahoo 360 is by far the most popular blogging service here, and it loads much faster in Hanoi than it does in the States.)

Before this trip to Vietnam, I always had a lingering feeling that my family and friends were missing out on top-notch American online protection. Now I realize we Americans are actually the ones who having been missing out on some great software and services, but hopefully not for too much longer. Quang told me BKIS is working on making its software and services available outside of Vietnam in 2009.

In the meantime, you can download and try the free version of the BKAV software; the software comes with both Vietnamese and English interfaces. The commercial version costs only $299,000 dong ($17) for a one-year subscription, much less than the cost of its American counterparts.

Personally, I am highly impressed by how BKAV works and the way BKIS is run. It's ironic, however, that a lot of Vietnamese, mostly adults, would probably argue that BKAV is in no way comparable with other protection software solutions developed outside of Vietnam, especially in America, simply because it's made in Vietnam.

Vietnam is a super-friendly country, sometimes to the point of xenophilia, when it comes to products. Maybe that's why KFC is such a popular place. But hey, go to the fast-food joint and have an order of highly processed fried chicken and a large soda, then tell me if that's really more satisfying than a plate of spring rolls served with spicy fish sauce or an order of sticky rice sprinkled with shredded pork and crispy, roasted sliced onions.

On second thought, tastes differ, so don't tell me anything. But trust me that when it comes to BKIS, you're in good hands.

Dong Ngo is a CNET editor who covers networking and network storage, and writes about anything else he finds interesting. You can also listen to his podcast at insidecnetlabs.cnet.com. E-mail Dong.
Recent posts from Crave
Nokia shows off the BH-804 Bluetooth headset
News of home theater tech from LG comes streaming in
Iriver's Wave Home: All-in-one communications/multimedia hub gets some buzz
Photos: Samsung's new LED-backlit LCDs
Photos: Palm previews the Pre at CES
Sony steps out in a big (and little) way at CES
Adesso rolls out two keyboards with unique touchpad system
Entry-level Panasonic plasmas get Infinite Black
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 40 comments
by tm_13 December 1, 2008 7:23 AM PST
wow... this is amazingly incredible! although i've heard of BKAV as a really effective antivirus software, i never knew how it works! now as i've got a clear idea of how it functions, i'm totally impressed.. and yes, proud of being vietnamese even more!
Reply to this comment
by tm_13 December 1, 2008 7:25 AM PST
... and thank you for taking time out of your vacation to write such an interesting article!
Reply to this comment
by inachu December 1, 2008 8:23 AM PST
Another tool to keep me and my friends computer fast and infection free thanks!
Reply to this comment
by Clarious December 1, 2008 8:24 AM PST
Oh please, I don't think BKAV is that great, I even think that sometimes it is even more dangerous than viruses.

Current version of BKAV is using a very old engine, as you can see in the screenshot, its title is "bkav 2006", it is incapable of protect again many threats like rootkit or even do real time scanning. Well, it has real time scanning option but I have never seen it worked once, here in VN viruses mostly infect via autorun file in USB, so simply scan the USB for virus before let windows check the USB will protect you against at least half of viruses here, but BKAV can't even do that.

The engine was written by Mr Quang, while the script to dis-infect the file is written by other people, some of them are student in my university, and they script sometime also helped to kill windows, as they are only part timer, so they don't take the job seriously.

There is also a paid version named BKAV Pro, I haven't used it yet so I can't say for sure, but recently it has several copyright problem. The first is that they used code from a disassembler program that is under BSD licence, mean that you also have to included that licence if you redistribute binary version of software that use it, but BKAV pro didn't. The other is that they included rar.exe in their executable, which is illegal.

Someone may say "Hey, it is free! You can't expect much from it!" but trust me, it offers very little protection (no real time scanning = useless), and some time it also get rid of windows while cleaning virus. There are a lot of good anti virus out there, but I don't think bkav is one of them.

There are more to say about BKAV but I think this is enough. Oh, and I am a student learning in the same university that Mr Quang did, have meet him several time, used BKAV since the DOS time, so I think I know more about it than a lot of people. :)

So please, stay out of BKAV!
Reply to this comment
by RicABlair December 1, 2008 9:24 AM PST
Clarious, BKAV may not be all that you want it to be, or that it should be, but from my scant info on it, it is better than anything out there now. In the land of the blind, the one eyed jerk is king; in the land of AV S/W, anything better than Norton, McAfee, etc. etc. etc is king.
by svk1069 December 1, 2008 10:33 AM PST
Are we looking at the same screenshot? Perhaps CNet updated it. The screenshot I see says BKAV 2008 updated 30/11/2008.

I'm balancing the gushing article with your comment.

I'm curious. If BKAV is so good, why hasn't it been heard of much in the U.S.? Is it the language barrier? It's not like other foreign anti-virus products haven't made it big here, so why not BKAV? That makes me a little suspicious.
by Clarious December 1, 2008 6:03 PM PST
I won't know about the screenshot, I remember it was 2006 before :P

Ok, I will explain why I hate BKAV, this time shorter and cleaner.

BKAV is not truly an AV program, it doesn't protect your computer out of viruses. Because if lacks features like on access scanning or heuristic scanning. And because other AVs have these features, they are expensive and also a resource hog. If you want to clean you computer out of virus with a free, lightweight program, BKAV maybe useful. But I think the main point of having an AV program installed is to prevent your computer from being infected with viruses.

Also, I don't use any AV program, I just backup my file frequently, don't click suspicious links, disable autorun on all drivers, and I only got 3 virus in nearly 4 years. To clean them I use IceSword, a really good anti rootkit program, but also can be used to clean your computer out of anything.
by mcnubins December 1, 2008 8:57 AM PST
I like it. Smooth interface, not a resource hog. Running it concurrent with AVG seems to not be an issue. It was also able to clean a few things that AVG had not found. Nice addition to an existing anti-virus cocktail. Not sure if I trust it to be my sole source of protection but then again I don't trust any program for that these days.
Reply to this comment
by vunguyenthai December 1, 2008 10:37 AM PST
BKAV is a suck antvirius I've ever used. Its Its recognition of virus is really bad, and in the short way this article is for promotion!
Reply to this comment
by chanhdat December 1, 2008 10:59 AM PST
I totally agree with you at this point. I did have to reinstall Windows, because it deleted my system files. Not only me, but many friends of me were in the same situation. But now, I use Linux :p
by renGek December 1, 2008 12:35 PM PST
I am skeptical. Article says installation took 1 second. But near the end he says the product took up 13 megs. Writing 13 megs alone should take more time than that.

There are lots of really good anti-virus out there (mcafee is not one of them) and unless benchmarks are done that totally kicks their butt, there is no reason to switch. If an article shows it beating out avira, avast etc. then it will get my attention.
Reply to this comment
by ferretboy88 December 1, 2008 1:44 PM PST
Avira is a really good free anti virus. Very light on the system.
Reply to this comment
by Gareee December 1, 2008 3:29 PM PST
I don't see anywhere to actually buy the pro version, and if it is on the site linked, it's not in english.

Not sure I want to purchase something where I can't even read the help file (they are in Vietnamese)
Reply to this comment
by Iria00 December 1, 2008 4:39 PM PST
Well, the article says:

"Quang told me BKIS is working on making its software and services available outside of Vietnam in 2009. "
by Loki2012 December 1, 2008 5:10 PM PST
After downloading the file I ran a scan on it via Avast. It turns up a virus - Win32:Virut-IJ. It seems odd that Cnet would do a review without checking on the download. Anybody else scan the file? Is Avast trying to prevent compitition? I am not getting much information about the virus, if that is what it is. Anybody else?
Reply to this comment
by Clarious December 1, 2008 5:48 PM PST
Oh, BKAV use some techniques to change the system, so other AVs may mis detect it as a virus. This has happened before with KIS, but thay has fixed it IIRC. Don't worry, it is not a virus, it just use virus technique (doesn't sound very convincing er?)
by SophieLaffitte December 2, 2008 3:22 AM PST
From what I knew, Norton Antivirus was mistakenly flagging some windows files, Yahoo Mail and even NASA?s software as virus. McAfee flagged Excel files as malware (containing malicious code) that cause many Office users panic. Even Kaspersky recognize Windows Explorer as virus and cause the system hangs, no taskbar, no desktop.
by Loki2012 December 2, 2008 8:55 AM PST
Thanks for the info!
by chiphu December 1, 2008 7:42 PM PST
Oh come on. Some of you got your spit wasted. Just, once again, make a poll and see how many people (Vietnamese only I guess) will take the stuff for granted!!!
Reply to this comment
by faboumen December 1, 2008 8:37 PM PST
I installed it on a computer. It does install incredibly fast. I couldn't believe it was installed already.

What I'm not clear about--does this free version provide real-time protection, or is it just an on-demand scanner? I don't see any indication in the GUI of real-time protection.
Reply to this comment
by Clarious December 1, 2008 9:35 PM PST
On demand scanner only
by vunguyenthai December 1, 2008 10:30 PM PST
BKIS said that BKAV supported real time protection, but beleive me, that feature will never work at least once!

Use at your own risk ;)
by vinhkhanhle December 1, 2008 9:14 PM PST
Do not worry, do not even think about this BKAV because this antivirus software is a crap, only kills "Vietnamese viruses" (worms only) which mostly spread on USB Flash Drive and that's the only thing it can do. When comparing BKAV to other antivirus software, like Norton or many others, you are actually compare a trash can to a brand new Honda Civic 2009
Reply to this comment
by ca_sau December 2, 2008 1:36 AM PST
Oh, please try at your own risk, don't just hear Mr. Qu?ng said.
(i tried and very disappointed)
Reply to this comment
by bruceslog December 2, 2008 1:44 AM PST
Website says this A/V application does all of this;

Virus Defintions Updated (Manual) Daily
Real time scanning
Full Scanning
On-access Scanning
On-demand Scanning
Smart Scanning
Scheduled Scanning
Heuristic Scanning
Manual Scanning
Memory Scanning
Rootkit Scanning
Adware/Spyware Scanning
Trojan Smart Blocking
Anti Keylogger
Auto-Clean Infected Files
Auto-Clean Driver Files
Auto-Clean Startup Files
Detailed Virus Information
Manual Definition Updates
Manual Program Updates
Auto Defense
History/Report
Phone Support
Email Support


Seems they've worked on the programs abilities in the years since some of the posters below had their complaints about the program ? Scanning, in particular, seems to have several options, including Real Time, Full, On Access, On Demand, Smart Sacnning, Scheduled, Heuristic, .Manual, Memory, Rootkit, etc... how many scanning options do some folks
want ?
I'm gonna download it and put it on a spare off network machine and give it a test.
Reply to this comment
by gmorgan1001 December 2, 2008 3:15 AM PST
Hmmmm. Looks like Kaspersky to me. BKAV & BKIS. Kaspersky has KAV and KIS and has very similar branding. Good luck to them!!
Reply to this comment
by ahives December 27, 2008 7:16 AM PST
Bkav 360 also sounds a bit like Norton 360. :)
by vinhkhanhle December 2, 2008 4:53 PM PST
when you want to try it, try it!!! HOWEVER, this antivirus (I, actually, think it is antivirus without "anti") does not work as advertised (not even 10% functioning as advertised) because in Vietnam, people there do not have any antivirus software "made in Vietnam" (they did have one or two more but they were dead long time ago), it becomes number 1 of...1. Vietnamese government "recommends" individuals/companies/organizations in the nation "should" use this crap, because the organization (university) makes this crap is "closely" related to the government . With the "help" of government, many Vietnamese newspapers try to "fulfill government's dream", newspapers always press good words for this BKAV thing.

This crap is only 4MB for installation package but claims it can kill 1.4 millions viruses/worms/etc and Mr. Quang dares to say that it is even better than many antivirus software including Norton, Norton Symantec, McAfee, etc because the others antivirus software will destroy the operating system while BKAV does not. This news has been pressed on many Vietnamese online news websites.
Reply to this comment
by botaydotcom December 2, 2008 5:47 PM PST
I don't know much about the specs or technology behind BK, but I can say this: I've seen the software sitting there on many a computer that is riddled with viruses. I think if the user knows how to utilize it perhaps it may be effective? But for Vietnamese in particular and most average users in general, they need something that is going to protect them in advance and without their initiative. BK just doesn't seem to that and until it does it's not a solution for Viet Nam or the rest of the computer world.
Reply to this comment
by Xelkos December 3, 2008 2:51 AM PST
I have BKAV installed with trend Micro, and it works well for macro viruses. It's funny, I had ZomeAlarm pro in for years, Trend Micro the same, and scanned with every commercial Av program out there. Yet BKAV found 33 macro viruses that the leading competition did not find, and I thought I had a pretty smooth-running OS.

I did have this laptop in use on college campus with full security running. I would know when anyone was trying to make contact, and blocked them. I had used files from a USB drive that I shared on the campus machines, and also with the local Job Service; USB drives need some protection, they are a weak link.

Was curious whether BKAV would run in a 64 bit version of Vista, since the UI shows Win9x/2K/XP. So I decided to throw it on my Vista x64 OS, and guess what? It installed in like 2 seconds. Thankfully there are no macro viruses reported.
It does function under Vista x64, and it installed to the x64 Program Files, not the compatible x86 Program Files folder. And ran well, unlike many software programs.

Whether how strong it is, I don't know yet. There is an icon in the system tray that does indicate Aurtomatic protection, as it has a Disable Auto-Protect in the options.
Reply to this comment
by anti_intermilan December 3, 2008 9:30 AM PST
I come from Vietnam and I used to trust in BKAV. What did I recieve ??? I had to reinstall Windows many times.
Why U shouldnt use BKAV:
1. It doesnt have "real-time protection" in version free and version paid (the version BKAV Pro only has auto-update)
2. When you scan your computer with BKAV, sometime BKAV says that it has deleted the virus (includes the file was edited by virus) but actually, it hasnt... lol... you restart your computer, and rescan, BKAV still says the same but the virus isnt deleted...

Listen me, dont use BKAV... it's a "virus"
Reply to this comment
by Benoneya December 18, 2008 5:30 PM PST
I find it highly doubtful that anyone here on CNet would recommend anything harmful to your computer. Some of the time when an AV program fails the contributing factors are the way the users set it up. Same for firewalls. Someone who doesn't know how to use the product or doesn't read the help files and information that comes with the product uses it improperly. Then they blame the product.

That's not to say, however, that some products aren't better at what they do than others. But user error can play a great big part in product failures. And if you read the article, the man said he tested it himself. Soooo, who do I believe, some anonymous, faceless people with unknown motives, or someone with a good public reputation? That's a no brainer.
 See all 40 Comments >>
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

In the news now

Yahoo's Decker strong contender for CEO

Sources say the president of the embattled Internet search pioneer has been through two rounds of interviews with the board.


CES 2009

CES 2009 is in full swing. Highlights so far include Palm's WebOS and Pre device, Microsoft's Windows 7 beta, and much more.


advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right
-->