• On The Insider: Robert Downey Jr Injured on the Set

February 28, 2007 12:55 PM PST

Symantec incorrectly flags Yahoo Mail as a virus

  • Print
Yahoo's e-mail service is not infected with a computer virus, despite a warning from Symantec that says it is.

Starting sometime on Tuesday, accessing the beta version of Yahoo Mail on a PC with Symantec's updated antivirus software caused alarm bells to go off. The security software reported finding the "Feebs" worm on the Yahoo Web pages.

That warning was in error, Symantec said Wednesday.

"Symantec antivirus products...triggered a false-positive alert with Yahoo Mail beta," Vincent Weafer, a senior director at Symantec Security Response, said in an e-mailed statement.

Symantec started receiving reports of the incorrect warnings Tuesday evening, after it had sent out the latest antivirus definitions for its products. Symantec issued updated definitions later in the evening to fix the mistake, Weafer said.

"Given the timeliness of the response and the limited number of products which would have used those (incorrect) definitions, we expect the impact of this to be very limited," Weafer said, adding that Symantec received about a dozen reports from people who saw the false warning.

While Symantec downplayed the issue, the SANS Internet Storm Center reported that multiple people have seen the Symantec warning appear on their PC. One CNET News.com reader in an alarmed e-mail wrote that Yahoo Mail appeared to be hacked.

Such errors happen occasionally with security software. For example, Microsoft's Windows Live OneCare in November warned that Google's Gmail contained a virus. Earlier last year, McAfee's security tools flagged Excel and other legitimate applications as viruses, and Symantec last summer identified a Church of England software program as spyware.

Typically, these errors can be fixed by updating the signature files in security applications. These signatures are the rules used by the security program to identify malicious software.

See more CNET content tagged:
Symantec Corp., Yahoo! Mail, Yahoo! Inc., antivirus software, virus

Add a Comment (Log in or register) 11 comments
Is this really a mistake?
by Hoser McMoose February 28, 2007 2:15 PM PST
Given how excruciatingly slow Yahoo's new beta mail site is, is that really a mistake? Ok, admittedly Symantec got the name wrong, it's not a "Feebs" worm, but I would still tend to consider it malware of some type or other!
Reply to this comment
Maybe call it ILLWARE well intentioned but broke.
by disco-legend-zeke February 28, 2007 2:48 PM PST
but blame a lot of internet site havoc to DOS terrorism or extortion floods.

because the Internet (capital I, a registered trade Mark) is a cooperative, abuse of any member harms us all.
Is there any such thing as a 'computer virus'?
by Macsaresafer February 28, 2007 2:35 PM PST
"Yahoo's e-mail service is not infected with a computer virus,
despite a warning from Symantec that says it is."

It seems to me that if there is such a thing as a computer virus, it
would have to affect more than just systems that are using
Microsoft software!
Reply to this comment
and... Windows Mail thinks DNCC fund raiser emails are phishing.
by disco-legend-zeke February 28, 2007 2:39 PM PST
maybe bill is on to something here.

politics aside, at least it gets flagged and left on the inbox screen. Stuff dumped in the spam box can remain undiscovered untill my boredom level makes me read it.
Reply to this comment
That's why I love MS haters
by Jess McLean February 28, 2007 4:52 PM PST
They can blame Microsoft for everything and anything, even though this story has nothing to do with MS.
Reply to this comment
happened to me
by yoyoyo33 February 28, 2007 7:11 PM PST
This happened to me this morning. I am glad it was a
false positive reading:)
Reply to this comment
Symantec actually makes a mistake??????????!!!!!!!
by pentium4forever March 1, 2007 10:23 AM PST
Symantec actually made a mistake, yes they are not perfect like they sometimes try to act like they are. Flagging something as popular as Yahoo Mail as a virus is quite embarrassing.
Reply to this comment
Symantec should...
by Heebee Jeebies March 1, 2007 10:43 AM PST
Flag their own products as a virus. If you look at what a virus does and what Symantec's own products do it is very similar. They both mess up a system, they both consume resources, they both interfere with the day to day use of the system and on and on. The only real difference is the virus is free and Symantec's products aren't.

Robert
Reply to this comment
Buying Symantec is a mistake
by Schratboy March 1, 2007 10:59 AM PST
Hmmmm? So, just because one company has bought up a whole bunch of security companies and puts their label on them, does this make their products good? No. Any dolt that bases their security purchase decision on one so-called end-to-end security solution provider gets what they deserve: over-spending and an insecure operation.

Surely, there are those IT buyers who must justify their over-inflated salaries and bloated budgets, so spending 100,000s of dollars on crap equipment and software plus their minions must attend to is a fair trade-off. Does all the automation really make them safer and compliant? If you ask me the jury is still out. Anybody heard when we'll all be able to stop worrying about network security? Shhhhh. Don't tell the Symantec stockholders: it's a joke.
Reply to this comment
Symantec profiting from their "mistake"
by rth98122 March 2, 2007 12:40 PM PST
If you Google yahoo and w23.feebs there is a sponsored result that comes up from none other than Symantec as follows:

Sponsored Links

Worm Attacks Yahoo E-Mail
Protect your PC with Norton
AntiVirus software. Download now!
www.symantec.com

Symantec should be apologizing for their error, not profiting from it. My opinion as a result of this is that Symantec no different than any other malware out there.
Reply to this comment
Symantec profiting from their
by rth98122 March 2, 2007 12:41 PM PST
If you Google yahoo and w23.feebs there is a sponsored result that comes up from none other than Symantec as follows:

Sponsored Links

Worm Attacks Yahoo E-Mail
Protect your PC with Norton
AntiVirus software. Download now!
www.symantec.com

Symantec should be apologizing for their error, not profiting from it. My opinion as a result of this is that Symantec no different than any other malware out there.
Reply to this comment
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.

More feeds available in our RSS feed index.

Markets

Market news, charts, SEC filings, and more

Related quotes

Yahoo (7.08%) 0.76 11.50
Symantec (4.51%) 0.50 11.59
Dow Jones Industrials (3.31%) 270.00 8,419.09
S&P 500 (3.99%) 32.60 848.81
NASDAQ (3.70%) 51.73 1,449.80
CNET TECH (3.64%) 36.93 1,051.13
  Symbol Lookup
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • Business Tech

    IPOs a thing of the past?

    At AlwaysOn Venture Summit West conference, investment bankers, venture capitalists, and private equity players weigh in on the prognosis for the IPO market.

  • Gallery

    Photos: Space station marks a decade aloft

    The first pieces of the International Space Station went into orbit 10 years ago. Now a full-fledged lab facility, it continues to grow.

  • Security

    Apple deletes Mac antivirus suggestion

    Apple removes statement to customers urging them to use antivirus software, saying that Macs are safe "out of the box."

  • Beyond Binary

    Microsoft-HP cashback saga continues

    Earlier this week a Microsoft representative indicated that a deal offering 40 percent cash back at HP.com would be restarted following Black Friday glitches. Now that appears less certain.

  • Video

    A toast to online wine A toast to online wine
  • Digital Media

    Conde Nast to shutter teen site Flip.com

    The teenage girl social-networking site plans to shut down on December 16, according to an e-mail sent to users.

  • Video

    Wi-Fi while you fly Wi-Fi while you fly
  • Gaming and Culture

    From Cy Young to video game fame

    Tim Lincecum, one of the best pitchers in baseball, was chosen to be the cover athlete for 2K Sports' next baseball game. On Tuesday, he did a motion-capture session for the game.

  • Green Tech

    Ta ta, Tesla

    Are the Valley-based VCs and big-wigs who back Tesla Motors really serious about asking the federal government for low-interest loans?

  • Gallery

    Photos: Top-rated reviews of the week

    Here are a few of CNET Reviews' favorite items from the past week, including Adobe suites, laptop bags, and a Panasonic flat panel TV.

  • Crave

    HTC focuses on phone design; acquires One & Company Design, Inc.

    Looking to concentrate on design, smartphone manufacturer HTC acquires San Francisco-based design firm, One & Company Design, to help create its future devices.

  • Green Tech

    Ford accelerates electric-vehicle plans

    In its turnaround plan presented to Congress, Ford says it will invest billions in fuel efficiency and introduce a family of hybrid-electric and all-electric cars.