Save energy. Save money. THDAugust 3, 2007 11:00 AM PDT
Week in review: Rights and wrongs on copyright
- Related Stories
-
Week in review: Clueless in Congress?
July 27, 2007 -
Week in review: Keyloggers and crime fighters
July 20, 2007 -
Week in review: Microsoft's cloudy future
July 13, 2007
The rapper, whose music is available through Apple's iTunes, is suing the company for copyright infringement, saying that his music publishers have not given Apple permission to offer the artist's music for download. Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated, the companies representing Eminem, demand that Apple stop offering downloads.
Part of the problem may be confusion over who owns the rights to downloads. Apparently, Eminem is asserting that record companies do not hold these rights exclusively. Apple pays a portion of the revenue it collects from Eminem downloads to Universal Music Group, which distributes the music, but not to Eminem's publishers.
Meanwhile, many bloggers feel they are being ripped off by automated digital plagiarism, in which software bots copy thousands of blog posts per hour and publish them verbatim onto Web sites on which contextual ads next to them can generate money for the site owner.
Such Web sites are known among Web publishers as "scraper sites" because they effectively scrape the content off blogs, usually through RSS (Really Simple Syndication) and other feeds on which those blogs are sent.
Lorelle VanFossen, a writer who has a popular blog about blogging, is frustrated by her near-daily encounters with plagiarism.
"I make my living from my writing, and when people take it because they are ignorant of copyright laws--or think that because it's on the Internet, it's free--it makes me really mad," she said. "It's stealing content, in my mind."
More typical conflicts over content use on the Net involve tech start-ups that are sued by media conglomerates for copyright infringement. Quite often, the defendants call on Ira Rothken, a medical researcher turned lawyer who has backed long-shot copyright cases. Rothken is defending TorrentSpy, a search engine often used by file sharers to locate pirated films. TorrentSpy is facing a copyright suit filed by the Motion Picture Association of America, the trade group that represents the top film studios.
In May, a federal magistrate judge ordered the company to turn over user information stored in its servers' random access memory (RAM). The courts have never before ruled that RAM, a computer's temporary memory, is a tangible document that must be produced and turned over to litigants in civil cases, according to legal experts. Rothken has filed an appeal, and on August 13 will try to persuade a U.S. District Court judge in Los Angeles to reverse the decision. At stake is nothing less than Internet anonymity, say some legal experts. If companies can be compelled to turn over RAM any time they face a civil suit, then no U.S. Web site can ever again promise not to share user data, according to Rothken.
Theft of content is one thing, but a tech trade group is accusing a handful of sports leagues and media companies of trying to intimidate the public by issuing inaccurate warnings about making "unauthorized" copies of their work, according to a complaint filed with the Federal Trade Commission. The complaint by the Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA)--a trade group that represents tech giants such as Microsoft, Google and Yahoo--names the National Football League, Major League Baseball, NBC-Universal, Morgan Creek Productions, DreamWorks Pictures, Harcourt and Penguin Group.
An example of what CCIA is referring to is the little speech that TV or radio announcers make during breaks in games. Most sports fans can recite at least a smidgen of the boilerplate. While the statements have become a tradition during professional football and baseball broadcasts, the CCIA claims such statements are false and are harmful to consumers and technology companies. Similar warnings can be found in books, CDs and DVDS, according to the CCIA.
Some CNET News.com readers also expressed frustration with the current state of copyright laws.
"With the way things are right now, consumers are not seeing any of the benefits of the 'digital age' and are instead seeing their rights slip away in a barrage of draconian laws," one reader wrote to the News.com TalkBack forum.
Around Washington
The Federal Communications Commission ruled that a valuable chunk of wireless spectrum will be open to whatever mobile devices Americans want to use, amounting to a political setback for traditional telephone companies and a partial win for Google. As was hinted in recent weeks, the FCC approved that requirement as part of broader rules for auctioning licenses in the coveted 700MHz analog television band.
See more CNET content tagged:
Eminem,
Week in review,
blog,
Apple Computer,
RSS
